Monday, February 6, 2012

Week 5: Sex Trafficking

This week, Week 5, marks the second-to-last week of the second part of our course, which as you know from the syllabus is entitled “What Counts as Sex Work.” In this section, we’ve been reading and talking about the various forms that sex work takes, the working conditions of sex workers at various levels of the trade, and the enormity and ubiquity of the global sex industry. So, as always, please be sure to keep in mind as you’re preparing for class on Wednesday that Jeffreys seems to be right: The global economy as it currently exists (i.e., neoliberal capitalism via the processes of globalization) cannot exist without the global sex industry, and vice versa. They each depend on the other for their survival.

Also keep in mind the equation that I wrote on the board during the first week of class:

SEX TRAFFICKING does not (necessarily) = SEX WORK

In other words, while those who are trafficked (whatever that means?) for work in the global sex industry do often (but not always) end up in prostitution (but not necessarily street level), those who are SEX WORKERS of whatever sort are not necessarily the “victims” of trafficking.

This is a key point to understanding the material reality that, yes, the (sometimes) forced migration of human beings is one of the largest money-making ventures in the world, third only to drug and weapons trafficking. However, the above equation is also key to unpacking some of the panicked rhetoric around trafficking, which when discussed by/in the popular media – and even (as you’ll see in your reading of US and Canadian government documents this week) by state and international governing bodies – tends to focus solely on SEX TRAFFICKING to the exclusion of other, more frequent forms of HUMAN TRAFFICKING for agricultural, domestic, or industrial labour.

We’ll talk more about this latter point after the break when we return to a discussion of trafficking by reading Doezema. But for the time being, I want us to focus on the material reality of the existence of SEX TRAFFICKING and what feminists are trying to do to solve the problem(s), one of which is that there’s simply no way to tell for sure how widespread the problem really is. The reasons for this are something that we’ll talk about on Wednesday.

U.S. TVPA and the annual TIP
One thing you’ll learn from reading my article is that the 2000 U.S. Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA), which follows the abolitionist UN Palermo Protocol, has become the global model for anti-trafficking legislation, and governments around the world (including Canada) have passed similar federal legislation. The three main goals of the legislation are nick-named “the three Ps”: prosecution, protection, and prevention. The problem, though, as Jeffreys and I point out, is that the U.S.’s objective in passing the original legislation was to protect U.S. sovereignty and keep out illegal immigrants engaged in transnational organized crime networks (which, as you you’ll read this week, have become identified as the primary perpetrators of all kinds of trafficking, human or otherwise).

As a result, the TVPA is not, at its foundation, about helping to end sexualized violence against women; in fact, since its implementation in 2000, the TVPA has enabled increased funds to law enforcement while actually cutting funding to feminist community-based organizations in the U.S. such as domestic violence emergency shelters and related services to which “victims” of trafficking might turn to seek help. Thus, the focus is clearly on the first P – prosecution – rather than on the other two, protection and prevention. Lots of U.S. feminists have critiqued the TVPA for this major flaw, but it continues to be used as the model for anti-trafficking legislation globally. Obviously, this is hugely problematic if you’re a feminist and your goal is to draw attention to and hopefully solve the problem of SEX TRAFFICKING, which usually (but not always) involves the exploitation of women’s bodies.

The TVPA established the U.S. State Department’s Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons and mandated that new office to, among other things, research and publish a Trafficking in Persons Report (TIP) each year. In this report, which has been published annually since 2001 and is considered one of the best global resources on global anti-trafficking efforts, the U.S. ranks countries in tiers according to how well (or not) each country is enforcing the TVPA on its own soil. Tier 1 represents “countries whose governments fully comply with the Trafficking Victims Protection Act’s (TVPA) minimum standards,” and that’s where Canada is. Tier 2 is a list of countries whose “governments do not fully comply with the TVPA’s minimum standards, but are making significant efforts to bring themselves into compliance with those standards.” The Tier 2 Watch List represents those countries that have been placed on Tier 2, but there seems to be an alarming increase in trafficking “victims,” there’s been a failure to provide specific evidence of anti-trafficking efforts, and/or the country knows things aren’t going well, but has made promises to improve over the course of the next year. This is where Russia is. Tier 3 is a list of countries that “do not fully comply with the minimum standards and are not making significant efforts to do so” (2011 TIP Report, http://www.state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/2011/ 164228.htm).

An interesting component to all this is that the TVPA is a U.S. law, yet the U.S. finds no conflict or problem in its insistence that other countries adhere to it, which is why so many countries have adopted similar legislation. They’re trying to get/stay on Tier 1 because once a country gets placed on Tier 3, they lose all U.S. aid monies. And this is, in part, how/why the abolitionist anti-trafficking framework came to dominate international politics. It’s also why the U.S. instituted the Tier 2 Watch List, because there are lots of countries on the 2WL that probably should be on Tier 3, but the U.S. needs them as allies for political purposes. Think Russia, for example. It’s a fascinating process having to do, again, with the primary goal of protecting U.S. sovereignty and preventing illegal immigration.

Another interesting little factoid is that up until 2010, the U.S. didn’t include itself in the annual TIP Report! It does now, and places itself, rather predictably, on Tier 1. Fun stuff, no?

Canada’s anti-trafficking law closely resembles the U.S. TVPA in its focus on the three Ps of prosecution, protection, and prevention. But, as you’ll see from the Department of Justice webpage, it adds a fourth P to the mix: promoting partnerships. This is a laudable and necessary goal, one the U.S. actually did incorporate into the TVPA when the legislation was renewed a few years ago. Unfortunately, as you’ll read in the RCMP report, this fourth P, like the others, is easier said than done, so be sure for Wednesday to figure out what challenges Canada faces in the enforcement of its anti-trafficking law.

Also, as you’re reading for Wednesday, be sure to pay attention to how important language continues to be in talking about and trying to solve the problem of trafficking. Even the notion of “trafficking” is, itself, potentially problematic. So, taking the lead I set in my article, do a feminist analysis of the RCMP document: Who are the “victims?” Who are the “villains?” Who are the “johns?” Why? What can you tell from the language used by the Canadian Department of Justice and the RCMP about the positionalities (review Agustin on this), theoretical frameworks, and ideologies that might be at the foundation of Canadian attempts to end human trafficking?

And lastly, compare the U.S. State Department’s assessment of how Canada’s doing with the RCMP’s own self-assessment. Are there agreements? Disagreements?

A Reminder
Don’t forget to keep track of your CRPs, which are due at the start of class on Mondays. Details about the assignment can be found here. Be sure to include all the required components as described and also remember to bring a copy to submit to me as well as a copy for yourself so that you can refer to it during class.

I’ll see you all in class! In the meantime, happy reading, and please don’t hesitate to stop by during my office hours or e-mail me at kawilliams(at)mtroyal.ca if you have any questions.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

WEEK 4: Military Prostitution and Sex Tourism


Before I launch into a discussion of this week’s juicy topics (the pun was intended!), I thought some of you might be interested in this blog post that discusses some recent conversations about policy and laws surrounding sex work and the continuing productive debates between and among feminists on the issue. Also, you may also want to check out the following websites:
Military Prostitution
With regard to our readings this week, one thing you’ll notice is that we’re for this first time this week thinking about the history of the global sex industry: What caused the industrial vagina? What political, economic and social events and circumstances enabled the sexualization/pornographication of culture?

Jeffreys argues quite rightly that a huge factor was the growth of military prostitution during the twentieth century. The twentieth century was the bloodiest century in human history; more wars were fought in the last century than in any other century in human history (although the twenty-first is shaping up to be just as nasty). And the nature of waging war changed drastically, as well. No longer did opposing armies set the time and place of battle, far from the civilian population. No longer were wars fought on horseback with muskets, knives, and bows and arrows. Instead, with the advent of new technologies such as mechanized and automatic weapons, tear gas, biological and chemical warfare, radar, satellite, and the like, warfare became impersonal, dehumanized and generalized to entire populations – including civilians.

Military prostitution is not a new invention. Governments have always needed some way to ensure the loyalty of their military personnel, a continued commitment to the objectives of violent conflict, and soldiers’ high morale during those long, dangerous days of drudgery on the front – or even back on the bases. There have always been “camp followers,” some of whom historians have argued with solid evidence, were most certainly prostitutes.

But the ubiquity and devastation of mechanized warfare during the twentieth century, alongside the processes of economic globalization, industrialized and globalized the notion of “camp followers.” This resulted in the current situation in which the availability of (predominantly female) sex workers to service (male) military personnel is a constitutive element of military life. You’ll start to understand how and why this process developed and how and why it continues to operate to great success when you read chapter 5 in Jeffreys and the article on Blackboard by feminist scholar Na Young Lee (with whom I also went to graduate school!). Pay attention, in particular, to the connections between the everyday R&R prostitution relied upon by militaries and the enslavement of women in Korea during the 1940s and 1950s and in the mid-1990s in Bosnia. Also, be sure to think about the notion of PEACEKEEPING, and whether peace can really be kept by carrying a gun and looking and acting like a soldier.

Sex Tourism
With regard to sex tourism, which Jeffreys and lots of other feminist scholars, argues is the logical descendent of the simultaneous convergence of military prostitution and economic globalization, we have to understand it within the context of global “development” policies.

But first, let’s be clear about what ECONOMIC GLOBALIZATION entails:

  1. There has been an increased emphasis on the role and power of the consumer-oriented market-place (i.e., who buys what, why, and where).
  2. Because of this, countries around the world (and smaller regions like states and provinces; think Alberta’s oil and gas industry) have intentionally adopted an export-oriented approach to production, focusing on making stuff to sell to others, elsewhere; this has meant moving away from making/producing stuff for and to ensure the health and well-being of their own citizens.
  3. Multinational corporations (MNCs) have created layers of labour ranging from the corporation itself to subcontractors to home-based workers.
  4. Structural adjustment policies (SAPs) have been implemented since the 1970s as a condition of granting “development” loans to countries, and these SAPs require governments, as a condition of their “development” loan from the IMF or World Bank, to radically restructure their economies to conform to rules and regulations of capitalism (Pyle 2001, pp. 66-67).
These four components of ECONOMIC GLOBALIZATION have collectively caused the gap between rich people and poor people in most countries to widen and has actually served to increase the number of poor people in the world, most of whom are women. As a result of economic globalization, “the wealth of the world’s 200 richest people is greater than the combined incomes of the poorest 41 percent of humanity” (Anderson and Cavanaugh 1999, p. 27). And that was more than 10 years ago. A lot has happened since then, including the ramping up of the military-industrial complex as a result of the events of September 11, 2001 and the resultant “war on terror,” which is also wreaking havoc in the lives’ of people who were already suffering the effects of economic globalization, but that’s a topic for another course.

In class two weeks ago, I discussed the money flow in conventional “development” projects:

Donor country (usually located in the Global North) --> IMF or World Bank --> In the form of a high-interest loan to the “developing” Global South country.

It is the last part of this money flow that’s most important, because “development” projects fuel economic globalization through SAPs (see #4 above).  But the material effects of SAPs on peoples’ lives in “developing” countries—and increasingly in the Global North—are in complete opposition to the goals and spirit of “development” as a word in the dictionary that suggests “progress,” forward movement, and “growth.” Rather, conventional “development” projects rooted in SAPs cause the very circumstances that most negatively affect women globally—and men, too, but differently—within the context of ECONOMIC GLOBALIZATION. This is key to understanding how and why SEX WORK and SEX TOURISM fit into the puzzle and processes of the global economy.

Countries in the Global South that have borrowed high-interest loans from the IMF, World Bank and other international financial institutions have to pay that money back. The countries then have to figure out some way to raise not only the amount of the original loan, but also the interest and pay it all back within the time frame dictated by the lending institution. And we’re talking in the trillions of dollars here, which is no joke. And one of the ways that the IMF and the World Bank suggest to countries that they raise funds is to bolster their tourism industries. The idea behind this is to get wealthy(-ish) people from the Global North to visit for vacations, conventions, conferences, etc. These are the people with disposable income and leisure time to take that weeklong trip to, say, the Dominican Republic or Mexico. And while they’re there, these tourists from the Global North will spend their money on restaurants, entertainment, shopping and so forth. The theory is that this influx of dollars or Euros enables the host country to raise money to pay back its loans.

And how do countries get their target tourists from the Global North to visit and spend their money? One of the ways in by making known within the right circles that “entertainment” can include a range of (indirect) sexualized and (direct) sexual services provided by local women and girls (and less frequently, local men, boys and transgendered folks). This is SEX TOURISM, and you might check out these websites for information on how they operate:

In Class on Monday and Wednesday
Remember to think of SEX TOURISM as part of the industrial vagina, so put it into its economic and political context within globalization: Who’s making the money? Why are women doing this work? Under what conditions do they work? Whom are they servicing? And make sure you understand Jeffreys’ argument that military prostitution has paved the way for sex tourism, specifically, and the industrialization and globalization of the sex industry, more generally.

Also, don’t forget to keep track of your CRPs, which are due at the start of class on Mondays. Details about the assignment can be found here. Be sure to include all the required components as described and also remember to bring a copy to submit to me as well as a copy for yourself so that you can refer to it during class.

I’ll see you all in class on Monday. In the meantime, happy reading, and please don’t hesitate to stop by during my office hours or e-mail me at kawilliams(at)mtroyal.ca if you have any questions.

Saturday, January 21, 2012

WEEK 3 -- MOBs, Pornography and Strip Clubs

As you know from the Reading & Discussion Schedule in your syllabus (pp. 9-11), we’ve spent the first two weeks of the semester reading about and discussing the many feminist approaches to and perspectives on the global sex industry. Starting on Monday, and continuing for the next few weeks up until Reading Week, we’ll be focusing specifically on the various forms of labour that “count” as sex work and explore the various forms they take and some policy recommendations for how to solve the “problem” (whatever that is, depending on whom you ask!). We’ll also be talking about working conditions and the costs and benefits to women who work in the global sex industry in various capacities.  

Before I get into details about next week, though, I want to make you aware of one thing: While the general consensus among us for the past two weeks has been that Jeffrey’s abolitionist position is too restrictive, do not discount the value in her analysis. I encourage you (a) to understand fully and be able to explain/offer evidence for her argument that since all prostitution constitutes violence against women, there is no such thing as consensual prostitution (remember: she doesn’t use the term SEX WORK, and you need to be able to explain that, as well) and (b) to fully embrace her notion of the INDUSTRIAL VAGINA. While it may be the case that some of us may not agree with her theoretical perspective, her argument is right on that NEOLIBERAL ECONOMIC GLOBALIZATION has made possible the growth of the global sex industry to the point that the global sex industry – and thus the (often) sexual exploitation of women and girls – is now an integral part of international political economy. In other words, it is “not peripheral, but central to the current capitalist project” (Jeffreys 42).Who benefits from this? Why? How? Under what circumstances? And who doesn’t?

Women around the world: How are they doing?
It is the economic piece in Jeffreys – the international political economy of the global sex industry -- that is the most important in her book and why I wanted us to read it in the first place, because the long and short of it is that the global status of women is not good. It is, in fact, dismal economically politically, and socially. Women around the world—including right here in Canada—are in seriously bad shape. Let me offer you some evidence and some examples:

First, statistically speaking, men around the world possess greater economic power than women. It is predominantly men who are in control of economies, financial resources, own more property and occupy more positions of power. Men hold the overwhelming majority of leadership and decision-making positions in business and banking. This has lead to what feminist scholars call the FEMININIZATION OF POVERTY, which is a fancy way of saying that the majority of poor people in the world are women.

Second, men have greater political power than do women. Although women do now have the right to vote in all countries (Saudi Arabia was the last country to pass women’s suffrage this past fall), significantly fewer women than men hold seats in national and municipal legislative bodies. There are precious few women presidents and prime ministers, and very few women hold appointed advisory positions, such as the U.S. president’s cabinet, for example. And when women do want to get involved in formal politics, they face extraordinary gender-based barriers, and if they do finally manage to hold elected or appointed positions, they are often forced to assume traditional styles of leadership that are heavily masculinized so that they can get anything done, which means conforming to the “old boys’ network” of formal politics that already pays little attention to the concerns and experiences of women.

The lack of women involved in formal politics around the world, either as leaders and decision-makers or as voters, is hugely problematic because male lawmakers are less likely to make laws that serve the interests of women and other marginalized groups. It’s just tends not to be on their radar screen.

Lastly, men around the world enjoy higher social status than women. This is how a PATRIARCHAL, ANDROCENTRIC society operates (remember that we defined these words during the first day of class). If men’s greater economic and political power is about the first two components of PATRIARCHY (i.e., male-dominated social structures combined with men’s perspectives, approaches and ways of doing thing), then the fact that men enjoy a higher social status than women is all about the third component of the definition: More value and importance is placed on the activities and characteristics of men, male bodies, and masculinity than on women, female bodies and femininity. This manifests itself in many, many ways; however, some of the most obvious are:

·         JOB PRESTIGE: Globally, women are almost always in less prestigious and lower paid jobs than men
·         SON PREFERENCE: Around the world, sons are more valued than daughters, which results in negative consequences for girls and women ranging from long term malnutrition and ill health (because boys get fed the best food first) to the extreme cases of FEMALE INFANTICIDE and SEX-SELECTIVE ABORTION.
·         The global ubiquity of men’s violence against women, including (but certainly not limited to) domestic violence, rape, dowry deaths, honour killings, and sexual violence and exploitation.

It is here, with this last example of how men’s higher social status manifests itself in men’s violence against women and the sexual exploitation of women and girls, that we start to venture into the territory covered by this course: the global sex industry. And it is also here that Jeffreys’ ABOLITIONIST position perhaps starts to make a bit more sense. As I said above, you don’t have to agree with her, but you do have to understand her arguments in the context of the global status of women as described above.

And one final way that men’s higher social status rears its ugly head is with use of the bodies of women and girls as commodities in every day exchanges. The long legal history of girls and women quite literally belonging to their nearest male relative is alive and well all over the world, and this notion of women as property to be exchanged, which Jeffreys discusses in chapter 2, has been at the foundation of Western feminist critiques of heterosexual marriage for three centuries.

Our classes next week
For next week, we’re going to focus on three aspects of the global sex industry: Mail-order brides (MOBs), pornography and strip clubs. The position of the latter two in the global sex industry is fairly apparent, but MOBs are a bit trickier, so be sure to pay close attention to Jeffreys’ explanation of how/why feminist theorists have historically been quite critical of heterosexual marriage as a SOCIAL INSTITUTION and have often argued that marriage and prostitution are “but two aspects of the one problem” (Jeffreys 39). What is this problem? Historically, why do people get married? And what role does GENDER INEQUALITY (i.e., women’s low social, political and economic status globally) play in this decision? The answer to these related questions is key to understanding why abolitionists are disapproving of MOBs.

So, as you’re doing your reading for Monday, don’t freak out and summarily dismiss Jeffreys’ discussion of the links between marriage and prostitution. If you must, throw the book across the room, take a breath, have some ice cream, and then try again, because her (and other feminists’) argument is crucial to understanding not only what’s going on with women’s low social, economic and political status, but also to the historical development of the global sex industry as constitutive of CAPITALISM, itself a patriarchal system. As the saying goes, prostitution is the world’s oldest profession, but that didn’t just happen; specific historical forces made it so. Thinks about what those might have been/continue to be.

Also, as you’re reading this week, please be sure to pay close attention, first, to how each of these three sectors of the global sex industry operates as a money-making venture (Who’s making the money? How? Who has the power? Why?) and, second, to the conditions under which sex workers in these three aspects of the global sex industry actually do their work. This is where your reading around in Nagle will come in handy, because the feminist whores who contribute to Part 1 address these issues specifically and offer sometimes contradictory and sometimes complementary information to that which Jeffreys presents.

On Monday, we’ll start where we left of last Wednesday with the questions about each feminist theoretical framework, so be sure to remember your notes from last week! After that, we’ll start to tackle some of the questions I’ve asked you to think about above, along with some of your own questions.

Also, don’t forget to keep track of your CRPs, which are due at the start of class on Mondays. Details about the assignment can be found here. Be sure to include all the required components as described and also remember to bring a copy to submit to me as well as a copy for yourself so that you can refer to it during class.

I’ll see you all in class on Monday. In the meantime, happy reading, and please don’t hesitate to stop by during my office hours or e-mail me at kawilliams(at)mtroyal.ca if you have any questions.

Friday, January 13, 2012

WEEK 2: Feminists and the Global Sex Industry

As you can see from the Reading & Discussion Schedule in your syllabus (pp. 9-11), WMST2207 is divided up into five parts. During this first part of the course, which we began last week, we’ll be reading and talking about feminists and the global sex industry.

You can already tell from our readings and discussions last week that jumping into a conversation among feminists about the global sex industry is, for those Harry Potter fans among us, a lot like watching a Quidditch match for the first time: Everyone around you is in a frenzy. They already seem to know all the rules, the players, and the team rivalries. And everyone’s got their opinions about who’s the best player. But eventually, if you work at it, you start to figure it all out, and Quidditch becomes not only accessible, but enjoyable. And you might even choose to join a team yourself.

This is what I’m hoping will happen as you start to read and learn more about the global sex industry, how and why it operates, and the various players involved in making it all happen. Analogies aside, my goal is to help you succeed in this course, and this blog is how I’ll provide information, clues, and questions to get you thinking about what’s most important in our reading each week.

At this point, I want to remind you again that WMST 2207 is not an introductory course. It is intended for second-year students who have already completed at least one full year of University-level coursework. Additionally, this course is student-driven seminar that builds upon the issues and concepts learned in prior Women’s Studies classes. It is therefore strongly recommended that you take WMST1172 or its equivalent before taking this course.

This information is not meant to intimidate you or scare you away. On the contrary, I want you to succeed, and staying in the course if you don't meet the prerequisites may adversely affect your situation. If you have any questions about this, or about anything else, please feel free to send me an e-mail at kawilliams(at)mtroyal.ca or drop by anytime during my office hours.

Now, let’s get started:

Feminist Frameworks
Last Wednesday, I asked you to answer several questions about that day’s reading, the last of which was, “What seem to be the political and ideological differences between each of the four key texts we’ll be using throughout the semester?”

This is the question that will frame our discussion this week. Our goal will be to identify the predominant feminist approaches to the “problem” of what I, a feminist researcher with my own positionality (Koken, in Ditmore, et al., 29-31) call SEX WORK. As we discovered last week, even language matters and reveals the foundational assumptions and premises upon which individual researchers, policy makers, pundits, journalists, legislators, and so forth base their analyses and suggestions for solving the “problem” of the global sex industry. Even what counts as the “problem” is different for each approach to this heated and complex conversation.

So, as you read this week’s materials, try to read them in the order that I’ve listed them on the syllabus. Jeffreys, an ABOLITIONIST FEMINIST, provides an excellent introduction to the various feminist frameworks that constitute the debate, arguing that feminist theorists in the late 20th century became complicit with neoliberal economists and economic globalization by conceptualizing what she calls PROSTITUTION as labour just like any other form of work. She argues that this position has been widely accepted by governments and international agencies “because it offers no challenge to the rights of men to buy women for sex” (16) and then goes on to discuss the various arguments that the SEX WORK POSITION uses, including the notion that prostitution is a form of reproductive labour, a focus on choice and agency, and the postcolonial approach. She then responds to these facets of the SEX WORK POSITION by describing the ABOLITIONIST FEMINIST position.

As you’re reading Jeffreys, be sure to get a good grasp of each of these arguments and the assumptions and premises upon which they’re based. But also be sure to remember that Jeffreys, an ABOLITIONIST FEMINIST, is telling her readers about all these other feminist frameworks in order to argue that hers is most appropriate.

So, that’s when you should turn to Outshoorn, who provides a review of the feminist debates concerning prostitution and the traffic in women from what she (and Agustin in Ditmore, et al.) terms a MIGRATION STUDIES FRAME, arguing that the term SEX TRAFFICKING should be replaced by the term PROSTITUTION-RELATED MIGRATION to more accurately reflect women’s agency within the systemic poverty caused by neoliberal economic policies and globalization (148).

I want you to read both Jeffreys and Outshoorn, because both discuss the feminist debates over the global sex industry, but Jeffreys does it using an ABOLITIONIST framework, while Outshoorn clearly represents the SEX WORK APPROACH, which is recognized by the UN Trafficking Protocol. As you read each theorist, try to (a) identify the problem she is concerned with and why, (b) figure out what she envisions instead, and (c) identify what strategies (if any) she suggests. This is the best way to start to understand the assumptions and premises at the heart of each position.

Although not required reading, you may find the following websites interesting, as they are helpful in understanding the evolution of international law regarding prostitution, sex work, trafficking, and the global sex industry, which tends to incorporate the SEX WORK POSITION by acknowledging that consensual sex work is possible:

·         UN CEDAW (1979)
·         UN Vienna Declaration (1993)
·         UN Platform for Action (1995)
·         UN Trafficking Protocol (2000)

Then turn to the chapters in Ditmore, each of which attempts to break away from the above dichotomy to present a new conceptual framework for understanding the global sex industry. In chapter 1, Brents and Hausbeck discuss the causes of the SEXUALIZATION OF CULTURE and what that might mean for sex workers, sex businesses, scholars and activists. In chapter 2, Agustin critiques the fact that the ideological and political positions of funders has restricted research on the sex industry to themes related to HIV/AIDS, “trafficking” and/or violence against women and argues that a more appropriate framework may well be MIGRATION STUDIES, which is also Outshoorn’s argument. And in chapter 3, Koken discusses the portrayal of sex workers in academic scholarship, arguing (as Agustin does) that available funding drives the very questions that are asked about the global sex industry and those who work in it. She contends that research must “be expanded beyond the narrow focus on women, prostitution, and the underlying moral attitudes” to include the economic, social, and cultural context of globalization.

After you’re done reading this week’s required materials and are, no doubt, thoroughly confused and reeling from the complexity of and disagreements embedded in the above materials, I strongly suggest that you return to Nagle’s Introduction, which you read for last Wednesday. As the editor of an anthology is comprised entirely of writings by current and former sex workers who also self-identify as advocates of feminism, Nagle insists that

Traditional feminism can no longer in good conscience advocate rape crisis centers while simultaneously refusing to talk to whores. Similarly, in its rebellious fervor, which I understand and share, sex-positive feminism mustn’t make the mistake of disavowing stop feminism (9).

There are, Nagle, suggests, commonalities among these seemingly disparate approaches to the global sex industry, and our task throughout the semester will be, to paraphrase Nagel, to engage with and deconstruct the dichotomy in order to uncover hidden areas of agreement (9). I encourage you to become comfortable with ambiguity and having more questions than answers.

Next Week’s Classes
You will have noticed that your preparation for class this week involves reading and thinking through some rather complex concepts that are, as you will learn, at the heart of feminist approaches to the global sex industry. As I said above, starting to engage with these debates is like attending a Quidditch match for the first time. Or, if you prefer, it really is like learning a new language. So, be patient with yourself as you read and reread in preparation for class on Monday.

Also, don’t forget that your first CRP is due at the start of class on Monday. Details about the assignment can be found here. Be sure to include all the required components as described and also remember to bring a copy to submit to me as well as a copy for yourself so that you can refer to it during class.

I’ll see you all in class on Monday. In the meantime, happy reading, happy writing, and please don’t hesitate to stop by during my office hours or e-mail me at kawilliams(at)mtroyal.ca if you have any questions.